Which AI Engines Should an Agency Prioritise? Start With Buyer Jobs
Choose where to invest by the decisions your client’s buyers need to make, then separate evidence of demand from the cost of learning.
The client wants visibility “everywhere”. Your team has enough time to investigate two buyer journeys properly or collect a thin set of screenshots from ten places.
Choose the two journeys.
An agency's first engine-selection decision should be about the buyer's task, the evidence available and what the team could change after learning something. An impressive list of monitored products is not a strategy if nobody knows which buying decision the work supports.
Describe the job before naming the engine
Write three or four situations in the buyer's own language. For a hypothetical commercial refrigeration supplier, these might be:
- “I need to understand why our current equipment keeps failing.”
- “I need a shortlist of suppliers that can support multiple locations.”
- “I need evidence that this supplier can handle our installation constraints.”
- “I need to explain the maintenance commitment to procurement.”
These are different jobs. One needs a useful diagnosis, another a credible shortlist, another detailed evidence. A generic prompt such as “best refrigeration company” misses much of that decision process.
Ask the client's sales and service teams which questions they actually hear. Review authorised, anonymised enquiry notes. Treat their recollections as leads to investigate, not a census of customer behaviour. A buyer interview can help, but a small interview sample should stay visibly small in the strategy.
Choose a product surface, not just a company name
Use precise names in the brief. ChatGPT search can return source citations. Google AI Mode is a Search experience supporting follow-up questions. These are identifiable surfaces to test, rather than interchangeable labels for “AI”. OpenAI search help, Google AI Mode help.
For every candidate, write down where the test happens, which features are enabled, the intended market and the buyer job. A consumer interface and an API evaluation should occupy separate rows. Do not silently substitute the easier collection method and retain the original label.
An agency need not declare one engine universally best. It needs a defensible reason to spend its next research hour somewhere.
Use a small decision matrix
Here is a proposed planning tool, not an industry benchmark. Give each candidate surface a short written assessment against four questions:
| Question | Stronger reason to prioritise | Reason to investigate first |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer relevance | Customers describe using it for this decision | Only the agency assumes they use it |
| Commercial importance | The question affects a valuable, suitable enquiry | The question is broad curiosity |
| Evidence readiness | The team can preserve comparable observations | Collection conditions are unclear |
| Ability to act | A specific page or evidence gap can be improved | The team would only produce another score |
Avoid a weighted score that hides a weak assumption. An account director should be able to read the reasons and disagree with them.
In the refrigeration example, suppose three recent buyers mention using ChatGPT to compare maintenance approaches. None reports how they first discovered a supplier. That supports a limited comparison-stage test. It does not establish ChatGPT as the client's largest acquisition channel.
The agency could investigate that job in ChatGPT search while retaining Google Search work for existing supplier enquiries. Perplexity or Gemini Apps might remain an exploratory row until there is a clearer research question. This is a hypothetical allocation, not a recommendation that those products matter less generally.
Set an expansion rule before the pilot
Decide what would justify adding another engine. Useful triggers include a recurring buyer question, attributable referral evidence, an important unanswered comparison or a request from a priority customer segment.
Also define what would not justify expansion: a competitor screenshot with unknown conditions, a vendor's aggregate score or a single surprising answer.
Allocate time to reviewing the findings, not just collecting them. If every available hour goes into more tests, the team cannot improve the service explanation, assemble practitioner evidence or resolve the implementation dependency those tests reveal.
Keep the limitation beside the recommendation
Write the conclusion plainly: “We are prioritising this surface for this buyer job because of these observations. We have not measured overall audience share.” That sentence protects the strategy from being repeated later as a market fact.
Review the choice when buyer evidence or business priorities change. Do not change it merely to make a monthly report look broader. Good SEO and credible, useful content remain part of the work; engine selection tells the team where to investigate, not which fundamentals to abandon.
For your first execution test, create a kloovy account. Bring one buyer job and one relevant page, then assess whether the workflow helps your agency turn the investigation into a reviewable next step.